Wednesday, January 20, 2016

Why Does Israel Have So Many Enemies? - By Rabbi Charlie Savenor


“Why Does Israel Have So Many Enemies?”

July 2014
By Rabbi Charlie Savenor


For the past week and a half Julie and I have been in Israel leading United Synagogue’s Family Israel Experience. Since there is too much to see, taste and digest in just 10 days, this type of first-timers program inevitably skims the surface of the country.

While our itinerary may have focused on the tip of the iceberg, ironically we spent much time beneath the surface. We marched through King Hezkeyahu’s water tunnels dating back to the Bible, helped excavate the Bar Kochba caves in Tel Morisha from the time of Maccabees, and were captivated by the underground “Bullet Factory” from the 1940’s.  In addition, today Israeli hospitals build their emergency rooms underground to safeguard against aerial attacks.

These subterranean hollows represent not only archaeological layers of civilization in Israel, but also the relentless pursuit of Jews to live in the Land. Understandably part of the story at these sites deals with our enemy at the time – Babylonians, Greeks, Romans, British and Arabs - and the outcome of that moment’s conflict.

On top of Masada, my nine year old son, Joseph, asked a question that had been clearly percolating in his mind during the trip: “Why does Israel have so many enemies?”


Our historical tours provided us with the what’s, when’s and who’s of Israeli history, yet Joseph’s seemingly naive question probed what lies beneath the surface. Why all these wars? Why do we keep hearing stories of expulsion and death? Why did we interrupt our regularly scheduled program for a memorial service for three Israeli teens?
 
His question may have also emerged from his awareness that while all of the children were shuttled to the Jerusalem Biblical Zoo, the adults went to a place that seemed to be off limits to children, namely Yad Vashem. The hushed conversations on the bus from moved parents and grandparents only made my nine year old - and I imagine many others - more curious about what happened during the Holocaust.

Every visit to Israel is special because there is always something “historic” going on. This time was no different. When we landed in Israel, the country still desperately hoped that the three kidnapped teens would return home safely. The very next day these hopes were extinguished like a candle in a desert wind. To make matters worse, a Palestinian teen was then abducted and killed.

Soon after the rhetorical escalation on both sides, missiles began to fly from Gaza into the State of Israel. Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, Beersheba, Ben Gurion Airport and even the nuclear facility in Dimona are under attack as I type these words.

Our family’s first exposure to the missile attacks took place in a cab on the streets of Tel Aviv. As soon as the driver heard the siren, he pulled the cab over and told us to get out and find cover. We ran quickly to a shelter and waited. Waiting for normalcy to return, I looked around at the assortment of strangers huddled together. Some were religious capped with kippot, others secular covered with tattoos. Some were old, others young. At that moment what united us was that we were all Jews, which, according to Hamas, makes us all targets.

When we got back in the cab, our driver casually explained with a shrug that these sirens are part of daily life, especially in Ashdod and Beersheba. In other words, this is normal life in Israel.

The next morning I sat on the balcony of our Tel Aviv hotel room enjoying the morning air gazing onto the beautiful blue Mediterranean. Julie was out running and the boys were inside watching Phineas and Ferb in Hebrew.

Then a siren suddenly disrupted the calm. Still in our pajamas, I rushed the boys into the closest stairwell being used as a shelter.

So many thoughts flooded my mind as my heart raced: Would this experience scar our boys’ view of Israel? Where would Julie find shelter running on the beach?  How could this regular race to shelter ever be described as normal?

As I held my sons tight during the siren, I was reminded of Joseph’s innocent, yet poignant question about the underpinnings of the hardships the Jewish people have faced throughout the generations. I thought about the conversations we needed to have when he and his baby brother would be ready - not just mature enough but also ready to embrace their place in the chain of Jewish history and the Jewish future.

With missiles flying towards us, my heart plunged to uncharted subterranean levels as I imagined that one day his children may ask him the same traumatizing question: “Why does Israel have so many enemies?”

Monday, November 9, 2015

Shattered Glass and Sorted Clothes



Shattered Glass and Sorted Clothes
By Rabbi Charles Savenor

Visiting Auschwitz is a transformational experience that evokes more questions than answers. We may understand the historical facts about Nazi Germany’s “final solution” death machine, but one can never understand what would motivate a modern nation to harness their resources to exterminate millions of human beings.

I recently led a trip to Poland and Germany for Park Avenue Synagogue with my colleagues, Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove, Cantor Shira Lissek and Beryl Chernov.  Our synagogue trip focused on the themes of tragedy and rebirth, a cycle repeated by Jews too many times to count in this part of the world. Even after Auschwitz, Jews once again have rebuilt their lives and communities as we saw firsthand in Warsaw and Krakow.

A day after standing at the ruins of the crematoria in Auschwitz, we departed for the second half of our trip in Berlin, a city still littered in my mind with shattered glass of 1938.  The question in the forefront of our minds was how German society deals with its unique legacy of mass extermination. On a simpler level, many of us wondered whether Germany has changed.

In the weeks leading up to our trip, headlines around the world focused on the most recent wave of refugees streaming out of the Middle East and specifically Syria, where their country has been ravaged by war and killings by their own people and government.

Equally interested in the present as the past, our group watched with great interest the refugee situation taking place in Germany today. While Germany has opened its doors to those in need, their government’s unilateral action is complicated and riddled with unintended consequences.

First, there are scores of shelters and camps for the refugees just in the Berlin area, yet there is little infrastructure for this massive undertaking across Germany. Staffed mainly by volunteers, these shelters have been organizing systems as they go. Shelters have made it clear to their local officials that photo ops are less important right now than creating homes for newcomers. 

A second unintended consequence has to do with the refugees’ political orientation. There is some concern that Muslim refugees are from countries where democracy is not the bedrock of their society.  The fact that some of these countries are explicitly anti-Israel may create future complications for Germany, which recently celebrated 50 years of diplomatic relations with Israel.

Third, some members of the Jewish community have experienced this opening of the gates with bittersweet emotions. They certainly admire the great humanitarian efforts of their government, but the public elevation of tolerance and diversity has reopened an old wound about the plight of Jews that many local senior citizens still remember. 

Furthermore, a floodgate of “what if” questions has opened about the not so distant past that still hovers over modern Germany like a dark cloud. What if German citizens had done more 70 years ago to stand up against Nazism? What if the League of Nations and Catholic Church had demanded that morality and humanitarianism be the standard? What if the world had opened its doors to Jews seeking sanctuary when life truly hung in the balance?

We were delighted to learn that the Jewish community of Berlin has been playing an active role in helping with the Syrian and Middle Eastern refugees for over a year. Our synagogue group was invited to not just donate clothes, but also to volunteer at one of the shelters. 

With a degree of trepidation and countless questions, we arrived at the shelter in Wilmersdorf that is run entirely by 1500 volunteers working 8 to12-hour shifts. After a brief orientation at the shelter, we were put to work sorting the countless boxes of clothes arriving daily for distribution.

For over an hour we worked with a variety of German citizens for the sake of people seeking safety for themselves and their families.  For a moment my mind was transported to a picture in Auschwitz that depicted the same kind of sorting of goods, but the difference was those were the spoils of war and these were donations from the heart.

Seventy years after the Holocaust the descendants of perpetrators and the children of victims and survivors worked shoulder to shoulder to help those in need. Side-by-side we worked to create a world that was different than that of our ancestors.

But that was not the only moment that stood out for me. Our Park Avenue Synagogue group was the first synagogue group from outside of Germany to volunteer at this shelter, and in many ways our visit was a pilot experience for English-speaking groups. It was clear from our yarmulkes that we were a Jewish group. During our visit we had some contact with refugees in the shelter where we stood next to one another, made eye contact and exchanged greetings for peace and security. What a miraculous and strange turn of events that in Berlin, of all places, Jews, Christians and Muslims could come together for a common purpose.

As we left the shelter that day I spoke with a woman who had been volunteering for over eight hours. Hearing about her experience, I expressed how inspired our group was by what we saw and thanked her for all that she's doing. With tears in her tired eyes, she responded: “I needed to do something. It's the least that I can do.”

At that very moment, I reflected on our question about where German society is today 70 years after Auschwitz. I would like to believe that these shelters reflect the society they hope to become and that the shattered glass of Kristalnacht many years ago has been mended and reconstructed into something positive for the sake of humanity.   

Only time will tell.

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Crossing Over and Jumping In



“Crossing Over and Jumping In” - Parashat Lech Lecha 2014
Rabbi Charlie Savenor

One of the bumps in Abraham and Sarah’s journey to the Land of Israel is the war between the kings, during which Lot, their nephew, is captured. Upon hearing the news, Abraham immediately springs into action to save him.

In the context of this biblical battle Abraham is referred to as "Ha-Ivri", which we understand as “The Hebrew”.  Since this is a regional conflict, it makes sense that Abraham’s allegiances be identified.  However, this moniker is complicated because “Ha-Ivri” literally means “one who crosses over”. Our traditional commentators believe that he got this name because he crossed over the Euphrates River to reach the Land of Israel.

According to the Midrash, this name is not about Abraham’s origins, but rather his place in the world. The rabbis teach that the whole world stands on one side, and Abraham and Sarah on the other. This is true not just in their acceptance of only one God, but also their commitment to justice, peace and action.

I believe that Abraham’s dramatic response to the news of Lot’s predicament teaches us another aspect of what it means to be an "Ivri". Embedded in our spiritual DNA is the inclination to cross over from passive spectators to history to proactive shapers of the future. To be an "Ivri" connotes the willingness to jump in when we can make a difference.

Another biblical figure who identifies himself as an Ivri is Jonah. This puzzling prophet receives his calling, and, instead of leaving for Nineveh, flees to the Jaffa seaport and catches the first boat out of town.

Only hours after setting sail away from Nineveh, God creates a storm to stop the boat. This storm is so horrible that every passenger on the boat prays to their God for help, except Jonah.  In order to attribute responsibility for the storm, they draw lots. No surprise to us, Jonah draws the short straw.

After explaining that he is running away from God, he assures them that he knows how to quiet the sea.  He tells them: “Pick me up and throw me overboard.” One can read this directive as Jonah’s desire not just to escape from his responsibility of going to Nineveh, but also his yearning to leave this world entirely.

While suicide appears to be one plausible explanation for his desire to be thrown overboard, I believe that there is a clue that Jonah's actions communicate other intentions.

With the ship in danger, the crew and other passengers turn to Jonah and ask him, “What do you do? Who are your people?”  “Ivri Anochi,” Jonah replies, “I am a Hebrew.” I am a Jew.

Witnessing first-hand a boat being battered by the sea and countless lives at stake, Jonah's description of himself sets off a flare gun in his heart, mind and soul. At that very moment, Jonah realizes he can save these people.

Through this lens, we might understand his words as not "Throw me overboard", but rather "Help me jump in".  Jonah knew what needed to be done to save a ship full of people, so he embraced the opportunity to make a difference.

With many challenges facing the world today, Abraham and Jonah remind us that we have a responsibility to act because "Ivri Anochi", we are Jews. The world needs our help, so now is the time to jump in.